News has just broken in the last few minutes that unsurprisingly, the government is giving the go ahead to their HS2 project.
Solihull Friends of the Earth would like to express their absolute disappointment at this short-sighted decision given by the government without serious consideration of the actual facts. As we have constantly made clear, the actual facts make it very clear that there is no business or environmental case. For more information, please see the response we gave to the HS2 consultation; http://solihullfoe.blogspot.com/2011/07/solihull-friends-of-earth-submit-their.html
Solihull Friends of the Earth will give a much more thorough response to this decision as more details emerge within the next few weeks.
What is your reaction to this decision ? Please feel free to leave any comments you may have on here. If you prefer, you can also email us your views on solihullfoe@gmail.com .
Tuesday, 10 January 2012
Wednesday, 4 January 2012
The Eco-Build, Solihull
Solihull residents Peter and Paula Knott are currently in the midst of a back land development, of two green eco-homes with a predicted completion of 2013. The homes will have green roofs, rain water harvesting, photovoltaic and solar thermal panels, mechanical ventilation, heat recovery, ground to air heat pipes and heat pump technology.
The couple are owners of a beautiful home on The Crescent in Solihull. Over the years they have been approached by property developers wishing to buy their land with the intent of building a development of 4-5 homes over this area. They however did not want to inflict such a development on themselves, or the neighbourhood, but they had found they had outgrown their home, with all their children having flown the nest. From this, an idea was born, to build their own smaller development on their land, preventing large scale property developers. The couple feel strongly about waste and improper use of energy resources, both having backgrounds in chemical engineering and past experience in their own small scale property developments, the idea of the eco built came to them.
Moving from imaginative idea to working progress has not been a smooth course. The original planning permission was initially turned down; however permission was eventually gained after lengthy consultation, with all points for which it was denied, being overturned by the inspectorate. General council support has been negative with comments such as “do tree huggers have this sort of money” and other issues such the effect of the development on the character and appearance of the area. However with the build being a back land development its impact is very minimal, especially garden roofs. The majority of the neighbourhood have had no objections and the couple have been very sensitive to any issues that have arisen. The Knotts are completely dedicated to the project and intend to sell their house and move into a caravan on site until one of the homes is finished. Once both homes are finished they will reside in one and the other will be put on the market.
The build began in July 2010, and is predicted to be complete sometime in 2013. A contributing factor towards the build was the Feed-In Tariffs, the government scheme that pays people for creating their own "green electricity”. Already within the space of the build, changes to this scheme have arisen meaning that the government intends to slash incentives for household solar electricity, and although disappointed the build may not see the benefits of the scheme Peter states that they are still fulfilling their aims to “live in a comfortable home and do the right thing”.
Looking closely at one of the two homes, it will be fitted with 9 PV-T (photovoltaic and solar thermal) panels; these panels are a single solar collector which produces electricity, heating and domestic hot water. Predicted figures show that they will produce an average of 5.23 kWh/day of electrical energy and 8.75 kWh/day of thermal energy, with a combined carbon offset of 1416 Kg per an annum from the panels alone. The building insulation will also be approximately double the current building regulations, and much of the water will be recycled within the property. The running cost of the house is predicted to be around 30 % less than a conventionally built home.
When asked to comment on the issue of climate change Peter stated; “Global warming is happening, even if some disagree about the causes. It seems obvious to me that we should do what we can to make our lives sustainable, and that includes building houses of quality which minimise the use of all our precious resources. From our point of view the local authority have shown passing interest in our housing development, but have missed an opportunity to learn more and perhaps use it as a means to encourage others to do the same”.
More information on the built can be found at www.at38thecrescent.co.uk/
Friday, 30 December 2011
Happy New Year !!!!!
We at Solihull Friends of the Earth hope that you have all had a very good christmas break.
We have been involved in a lot of things in 2011, Here are just some of these things;
* The Government's Energy bill and Friends of the Earth's national energy campaign
* Publishing a Fairtrade and Local Food directory
* HS2 consultation
* Birmingham Airport night time flying consultation
* Go Green Fair Event
* Fun in the Park Event
* Film Screenings (including increasing awareness of Durban Climate Conference)
* Plant Swap Events
AND MUCH MUCH MORE....
Last but certainly not least, we have gained many new members. Why not come and join us to make a difference to the local community in Solihull in 2012 and beyond ? New members are welcome. Please drop us an email on solihullfoe@gmail.com or by entering a comment on this blog for more information.
Find out soon our stated aims and priorities for 2012. It will be to carry on some of the campaign themes of 2011 and previous years but also to launch new campaigns which will be announced on this blog.
So finally, we at Solihull Friends of the Earth would like to wish you all a very happy new year and would like to thank everyone other parties who have worked with us during 2011.
We have been involved in a lot of things in 2011, Here are just some of these things;
* The Government's Energy bill and Friends of the Earth's national energy campaign
* Publishing a Fairtrade and Local Food directory
* HS2 consultation
* Birmingham Airport night time flying consultation
* Go Green Fair Event
* Fun in the Park Event
* Film Screenings (including increasing awareness of Durban Climate Conference)
* Plant Swap Events
AND MUCH MUCH MORE....
Last but certainly not least, we have gained many new members. Why not come and join us to make a difference to the local community in Solihull in 2012 and beyond ? New members are welcome. Please drop us an email on solihullfoe@gmail.com or by entering a comment on this blog for more information.
Find out soon our stated aims and priorities for 2012. It will be to carry on some of the campaign themes of 2011 and previous years but also to launch new campaigns which will be announced on this blog.
So finally, we at Solihull Friends of the Earth would like to wish you all a very happy new year and would like to thank everyone other parties who have worked with us during 2011.
Thursday, 17 November 2011
Monday, 29 August 2011
Solihull Friends of the Earth provide a formal response to Birmingham Airport's Night Flying Consultation
Solihull Friends of the Earth has provided a response to Birmingham Airport's Night Flying Consultation. A copy of the document is available at http://www.birminghamairport.aero/meta/about-us/environment/night-flying-policy-consultation.aspx.This is regarding being able to change noise limits and the method with which this is done.
The consultation closed on Wednesday 24th August 2011.
We welcome the reduction of the night noise violation limit from 87db - 85 db. However, the revision of annual limits for ATMs annually based on the previous 5 years is worrying. Despite showing noise trends of a reduction of noise impact on the population, there appears to be no commitment or strategy to reduce overall noise levels at night. Exempting Quota Count 0 aircraft which in themselves can have a noise classification of anywhere up to just under 84 EPN dB, and therefore the vast majority may have a noise of for example 83.9 EPN dB. The increase in frequency of aircraft (particularly now there is a runway extension) can possibly outweight the general welcome shift towards lower quota aircraft that has occurred. It is also surely reasonable to give projections of noise impact on the population; in business, financial and non-financial projections of operations have to be made and therefore there is very little rationale to not do something similar for projections of noise levels and impact.
Solihull Friends of the Earth believes that to assume that noise levels have to increase or decrease based on recovery or recession is not part of a commitment to decrease noise levels and its impact on the population.
We would also like to learn more about the number and type of flights that have moved from Coventry Airport to Birmingham as a result of the closure of that facility. We welcome the news that a new consultation period would be put in place if flights were ever to recommence from Baginton. We would appreciate if more detailed information and greater clarity could be provided regarding this issue.
Finally, we do have some concerns about removing the seasonal splits in ATMs (76% Summer and 24% Winter), and therefore would appreciate any greater clarity though we do also appreciate the reasons why Birmingham Airport are proposing this.'
Our response covers the important points and expresses our dismay of a almost non-existant strategy of noise reduction and/or reduction of the impact of noise on the surrounding areas. The presentation of data by Birmingham Airport showing an overall reduction in noise impact on the local population in the last ten years shows little relevance as to the impact on noise as a result of the changes resulting from the proposals in the consultation document.
Did you respond to the consultation ? Do you have any comments to make concerning this issue or is there anything to add? Please feel free to make comments either via the blog or emailing us at solihullfoe@gmail.com.
The consultation closed on Wednesday 24th August 2011.
Our response is as follows:
'We do recognise that consultation events took place at various locations in June and July. However, we are concerned about the low-key nature concerning potential changes in night flying policy that we believe will overall have a detrimental environmental effect on the population.
We welcome the reduction of the night noise violation limit from 87db - 85 db. However, the revision of annual limits for ATMs annually based on the previous 5 years is worrying. Despite showing noise trends of a reduction of noise impact on the population, there appears to be no commitment or strategy to reduce overall noise levels at night. Exempting Quota Count 0 aircraft which in themselves can have a noise classification of anywhere up to just under 84 EPN dB, and therefore the vast majority may have a noise of for example 83.9 EPN dB. The increase in frequency of aircraft (particularly now there is a runway extension) can possibly outweight the general welcome shift towards lower quota aircraft that has occurred. It is also surely reasonable to give projections of noise impact on the population; in business, financial and non-financial projections of operations have to be made and therefore there is very little rationale to not do something similar for projections of noise levels and impact.
Solihull Friends of the Earth believes that to assume that noise levels have to increase or decrease based on recovery or recession is not part of a commitment to decrease noise levels and its impact on the population.
Solihull Friends of the Earth don’t believe that there is an insufficient strategy to attempt to mitigate for increased noise levels. It’s very well to respond that any fines collected from exceeding the noise violation limit is put into ‘community projects’ but it is necessary to know what is going to be done as a result of increased noise because of the actual change in the night flying policy.
We would also like to learn more about the number and type of flights that have moved from Coventry Airport to Birmingham as a result of the closure of that facility. We welcome the news that a new consultation period would be put in place if flights were ever to recommence from Baginton. We would appreciate if more detailed information and greater clarity could be provided regarding this issue.
Finally, we do have some concerns about removing the seasonal splits in ATMs (76% Summer and 24% Winter), and therefore would appreciate any greater clarity though we do also appreciate the reasons why Birmingham Airport are proposing this.'
Our response covers the important points and expresses our dismay of a almost non-existant strategy of noise reduction and/or reduction of the impact of noise on the surrounding areas. The presentation of data by Birmingham Airport showing an overall reduction in noise impact on the local population in the last ten years shows little relevance as to the impact on noise as a result of the changes resulting from the proposals in the consultation document.
Did you respond to the consultation ? Do you have any comments to make concerning this issue or is there anything to add? Please feel free to make comments either via the blog or emailing us at solihullfoe@gmail.com.
Wednesday, 3 August 2011
Come and be a part of Solihull Friends of the Earth
Interested in green issues? Want to make a positive difference to Solihull and the community? Then come and be a part of Solihull Friends of the Earth.
We're campaigning on a variety of important issues such as local food, Energy, Transport and much much more. As you may see, we've recently been analysing the HS2 issue and we submitted our views to the HS2 consultation that closed on Friday 29th July. Our submitted response is shown in the previous post in this blog.
We've worked closely with Solihull Borough Council to publish the Fairtrade and Local Food directory (See relevant post at http://solihullfoe.blogspot.com/2011/07/solihull-foe-proud-as-fairtrade-and.html
To spread our message, we take part in public events such as the recent Plant Swap and Go Green Fair events. We are due to take part at the Fun in the Park event at Tudor Grange Park on the 25th September.
Want to find out more ? It's simple. Email us at solihullfoe@gmail.com and we can then arrange for you to join us at the following monthly meeting.
Thursday, 28 July 2011
Solihull Friends of the Earth submit their response to HS2 consultation
Solihull Friends of the Earth have submitted their response to the High Speed 2 Consultation.
Question 1:
Solihull Friends of the Earth is opposing HS2 as the trains will not take passengers off planes or out of their cars; most will be new journeys which would not otherwise have taken place. The sheer cost of the project is huge, and we believe that HS2 provides little gain, with even the claimed figures being speculative. The ticket prices will be high, which will make it a railway for the affluent rather than everybody and it will not improve local travel for the majority at all.
Other countries with similar links have found that rather than jobs spreading out from a larger place (London) to the satellite cities (Birmingham), the larger conurbation tends to gain even more jobs at the expense of the smaller place, thus working against the stated aim of distributing economic gains around evenly.
We are happy to provide the full responses we have submitted below;
Question 1:
This question is about the strategy and wider context (Chapter 1 of the main consultation document)
Do you agree that there is a strong case for enhancing the capacity and performance of Britain’s inter-city rail network to support economic growth over the coming decades?
Our Response: Solihull Friends of the Earth believes that increasing the capacity of rail by encouraging a shift away from cars is very important in the quest for a low carbon economy. However cutting journey times at the total cost of 38.2 billion pounds does not provide economic and energy benefits. The recent Oxera report to the Transport Select Committee states that most jobs created will be short term and in London. HS2 also jeopardises investment in local transport schemes in Solihull where local schemes linking Solihull and Birmingham, and North Solihull and Birmingham International train station are a much higher priority. Improvements to local transport systems would do much to support economic growth.
Solihull Friends of the Earth believes that instead rail coverage, reliability and punctuality has to be enhanced. Higher speeds don't necessarily mean increased reliability; this can be achieved by upgrading existing infrastructure such as train stock and platforms rather than spending huge amounts of money on an entirely new line, where the claimed benefits are speculative. The evidence provided in the consultation document is of a poor standard. The estimates are based on figures that are dependant on economic factors that the Government can't predict anywhere near accurately. We believe that the country cannot afford this project.
Our Response: No. Solihull Friends of the Earth believe there is no gain for communities along the route since they are not served by the HS2 rail service. All they gain is the detrimental effects of the HS2 line passing straight through them. The Oxera report to the Transport Select Committee queried the benefit of the speed of the line; reduced speeds would offer flexibility to allow the line to follow the contours of the land, thus avoiding the need for a destructive route. With respect to Birmingham Interchange Station, we don't believe HS2 encourages inner city regeneration in Solihull where any activity is restricted to outer Solihull which increases the factors threatening the surrounding Green Belt.
Question 3
Our Response: No. HS2 on its own doesn't represent a Transport Strategy. As already stated, a huge amount of resources are being put into HS2 yet the suggested benefits are dubious. There is no integrated thinking of creating, enhancing and linking local with national infrastructure in order to come up with a credible strategic plan. This is needed in order to meet all the environmental and possible economic challenges that are faced in the short, medium and long term.
Question 4
Our Response: No. The withholding of important information by HS2 Ltd has to be noted here. It needed Berkswell Parish Council to make a Freedom of Information request for it to become known that in addition to the 22m maximum width of the line, there is going to be in addition 25m either side of the line of what is described as managed vegetation. This in practice means that an even greater amount mature trees or plant species will be lost than it first appeared, and a total of potentially a 72m strip of vegetation being lost along the route of the line.
Question 5
Our Response: No. The route will have a significant negative impact on Solihull. The proposed route passes onto a viaduct in close proximity to Berkswell Station, with historic buildings and green belt land likely to be threatened. The proposed route also impacts on Chelmsley Wood, in particular the Bluebell Recreation Ground and Yorkminster Drive, where residential dwellings will be approximately 70 metres west of the route.
Question 6
Our Response: Solihull Friends of the Earth believes that no account is being taken of the need for sustainability especially in the knowledge of peak oil. This HS2 project cannot be considered to be sustainable when done at the expense of the natural environment. There has been no environmental impact assessment done on a local level.We believe that as transport links are concentrated near Birmingham Airport, it is bound to encourage an increase of long haul flights which will increase greenhouse emissions and pressure on the surrounding green belt. The increased travel generated by people in their cars who travel to Birmingham Interchange station will also increase carbon emissions. This again comes back to the point above concerning creating an integrated Transport strategy which is non-existent (the LTP3 itself just exposes how confused the thinking really is) which does not encourage a shift away from cars and hence enhance social mobility.
Question 7:
This question is about blight and compensation (Annex A of the main consultation document)
Do you agree with the options set out to assist those with whose properties lose a significant amount of value as a result of any new high speed line?
Our Response: No. The destruction along the line impacts on more than just properties which stand to lose value. There is a loss to the whole country of valuable green spaces and areas of local and historical importance. There can be no recompense for this loss, and those individuals who stand to lose access to green spaces will not be liable for financial compensation.
Are you in favour of HS2 or not ? Do you agree with Solihull FOE's position regarding HS2 ? Maybe you agree with us or alternatively you take a totally different view and believe HS2 to overall be a good thing. Please feel free to discuss further via your comments here or alternatively email us at solihullfoe@gmail.com .
Our Response: Solihull Friends of the Earth believes that increasing the capacity of rail by encouraging a shift away from cars is very important in the quest for a low carbon economy. However cutting journey times at the total cost of 38.2 billion pounds does not provide economic and energy benefits. The recent Oxera report to the Transport Select Committee states that most jobs created will be short term and in London. HS2 also jeopardises investment in local transport schemes in Solihull where local schemes linking Solihull and Birmingham, and North Solihull and Birmingham International train station are a much higher priority. Improvements to local transport systems would do much to support economic growth.
Solihull Friends of the Earth believes that instead rail coverage, reliability and punctuality has to be enhanced. Higher speeds don't necessarily mean increased reliability; this can be achieved by upgrading existing infrastructure such as train stock and platforms rather than spending huge amounts of money on an entirely new line, where the claimed benefits are speculative. The evidence provided in the consultation document is of a poor standard. The estimates are based on figures that are dependant on economic factors that the Government can't predict anywhere near accurately. We believe that the country cannot afford this project.
Question 2
This question is about the case for high speed rail (Chapter 2 of the main consultation document)
Do you agree that a national high speed rail network from London to Birmingham, Leeds and Manchester (the Y network) would provide the best value for money solution (best balance of costs and benefits) for enhancing rail capacity and performance?
Question 3
This question is about how to deliver the Government’s proposed network (Chapter 3 of the main consultation document)
Do you agree with the Government’s proposals for the phased roll-out of a national high speed rail network, and for links to Heathrow Airport and the High Speed 1 line to the Channel Tunnel?
Question 4
This question is about the specification for the line between London and the West Midlands (Chapter 4 of the main consultation document)
Do you agree with the principles and specification used by HS2 Ltd to underpin its proposals for new high speed rail lines and the route selection process HS2 Ltd undertook?
Question 5
This question is about the route for the line between London and the West Midlands (Chapter 5 and Annex B of the main consultation document)
Do you agree that the Government’s proposed route, including the approach proposed for mitigating its impacts, is the best option for a new high speed rail line between London and the West Midlands?
Question 6
This question is about the Appraisal of Sustainability (Chapter 5 of the main consultation document)
Do you wish to comment on the Appraisal of Sustainability of the Government’s proposed route between London and the West Midlands that has been published to inform this consultation?
Our Response: Solihull Friends of the Earth believes that no account is being taken of the need for sustainability especially in the knowledge of peak oil. This HS2 project cannot be considered to be sustainable when done at the expense of the natural environment. There has been no environmental impact assessment done on a local level.We believe that as transport links are concentrated near Birmingham Airport, it is bound to encourage an increase of long haul flights which will increase greenhouse emissions and pressure on the surrounding green belt. The increased travel generated by people in their cars who travel to Birmingham Interchange station will also increase carbon emissions. This again comes back to the point above concerning creating an integrated Transport strategy which is non-existent (the LTP3 itself just exposes how confused the thinking really is) which does not encourage a shift away from cars and hence enhance social mobility.
Question 7:
This question is about blight and compensation (Annex A of the main consultation document)
Do you agree with the options set out to assist those with whose properties lose a significant amount of value as a result of any new high speed line?
Our Response: No. The destruction along the line impacts on more than just properties which stand to lose value. There is a loss to the whole country of valuable green spaces and areas of local and historical importance. There can be no recompense for this loss, and those individuals who stand to lose access to green spaces will not be liable for financial compensation.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
